Victoria’s households and businesses face a double threat over the next few years: rising energy bills and a potential shortfall in electricity supply. The state’s largest coal plant is due to close in 2028, and experts warn that neither of the major parties has offered a convincing plan to fill the gap.
The Yallourn power station, which has operated in the Latrobe Valley since the 1970s and supplies about a fifth of Victoria’s energy, is at the end of its functional life and will shut in less than two years. All parties concede that much. What they have failed to do, analysts say, is properly explain how the shortfall left behind will be covered. The problem is made harder by surging demand from datacentres and by the electrification of buildings, homes and vehicles.
For the public, the stakes are concrete. Tim Baxter, of consultancy Naru Research, says there is no “time for a culture war on energy in Victoria” because poor choices now would be “devastating” for the state’s economy and create bill shocks for households and businesses. Cheap gas helped build Victoria’s past prosperity, he notes, but offshore supply from Bass Strait is in steep decline and there is no evidence of meaningful gas resources elsewhere to replace it. The result has been a 62% increase in gas prices over five years, alongside an 18% rise in electricity bills. Because Victorians rely on gas more heavily than residents of other states, he argues, the case for moving households onto renewable energy is urgent. “Every windfarm, solar farm and battery that comes online before 2028 reduces how much expensive gas Victoria has to burn when Yallourn goes. That makes speeding up the build-out the single best way to protect households from higher bills,” he says.
The Coalition, led by Jess Wilson and favoured to win the election, has drawn the sharpest criticism from experts. It says it would stop work on new transmission lines, the high-voltage connections needed to bring new wind and solar farms online and to let Victoria import power from neighbouring states. Specifically, it would scrap VNI West, a link to New South Wales, and pause the Western Renewables Link between Melbourne and the state’s west, replacing them with what it calls a “short, sharp and independent” review of the transmission plan, considering alternatives such as solar power on commercial and industrial rooftops. The Coalition has also pledged to “throw open the doors to gas exploration”, reverse Labor’s policy of making new homes all-electric, and tender for new firming capacity through an Energy Security Requirement modelled on schemes in NSW and South Australia. It has no plan to change the state’s emission reduction targets, which require cuts of 75% to 80% below 2005 levels by 2035 and net zero by 2045, but it has not said how it would achieve them.
Stephanie Bashir, chief executive of Nexa Advisory, says new transmission is crucial for developing renewable energy and importing power across state lines at times of high demand such as heatwaves. “This is not the time to be cancelling any of the projects in the pipeline,” she says. “This is the time where we put our foot on the accelerator and go hard.” Environment Victoria’s chief executive, Jono La Nauze, goes further, describing the Coalition’s plan, which includes reinstating a former Baillieu-Napthine government policy banning wind turbines within 2km of dwellings, as “the greatest swindle ever attempted on Victorian voters”. “The Coalition are promising to stop all the things that are necessary to replace our coal and gas generation. They’ve got some quick slogans for how they’re going to instead rely on gas, with absolutely no substance,” he says.
Labor, for its part, promises to keep expanding the grid, shift homes from gas to electricity, and support offshore windfarm development. In 12 years in government it has overseen Victoria’s renewable share rising from 10% to 44%, the closure of the Hazelwood coal station, windfarm numbers growing from 14 to 44 and large-scale solar farms from two to 57, and it ended the moratorium on conventional gas exploration in 2021. Yet analysts say it too is not building fast enough. Oliver Nunn, managing director of Endgame Analytics, points to electricity demand growing 5% year-on-year and says that with coal exiting and no really viable plan in place, “whoever wins [the election], we lose”.
Meanwhile, the state’s auditor general adds that both VNI West and the Western Renewables Link are behind schedule and unlikely to be completed before Yallourn closes. Labor’s attempts to speed things up, including laws allowing VicGrid and its contractors access to private land without a landholder’s consent as a last resort, have proved unpopular in regional communities. Victorian Farmers Federation president Ryan Milgate says that rather than improving engagement, “every time the government seems to hit a hurdle” it has changed legislation to give itself broader powers. Shadow energy minister David Davis calls these Labor’s “double bazooka powers” and says the Coalition will ditch them and reinstate landholder appeal rights.
Victoria’s wholesale electricity prices are the lowest on the east coast, but households still lean heavily on expensive gas, and a government briefing reported in the Herald Sun suggests bills are likely to rise regardless of who wins. A detailed comparison of the parties’ energy promises can be found at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/nov/22/victoria-election-2026-what-are-parties-promising-energy-policy. For the voters whose homes and businesses depend on the answer, Bashir’s closing plea captures the mood among analysts: energy policy should not be “a political football”. “We do need to back the replacement generation. We can’t do any more reviews; we’ve just got to get on with it.”